I'm a Britasian, I live in
Leeds and when I go out on a Friday or Saturday night. I'm very likely to go to
Townhouse at some point as it has the style of music and atmosphere I like. Out
of the many occasions I've been to Townhouse I've only been refused entry once.
On that particular night there was a long queue and I was definitely dressed too
casual. In fact, I went home, got changed and got in without any problems. Not
only that, but on numerous occassions I've seen many "white" guys get
refused at the door. Whenever I'm in Townhouse there is a predominant level
of Asian and Afro-Carribean people. Everyone's enjoying it and having a good time
and I've never seen any trouble. I think your report doesn't reflect on Townhouse
accurately. It may be true on certain nights if the management want less
ethnic groups to be in the club, which I can't comment on because that wouldn't
be on a Friday or Saturday night for sure. I've never been to Rehab but
I've seen plenty of ethnic groups go there too since it's opposite Townhouse.
I don't think it's a general policy either of these clubs hold to be honest. Zaz,
Leeds I was a regular at the Townhouse in Leeds prior to moving
to London. I can honestly say that I have never seen or heard any racial discrimination
from any of the door staff. However, as one of the most popular places
in Leeds to drink, it is notoriously difficult to gain entry. Not only
do you have to arrive at a time when the club is not heaving but you also need
to be smart/casual and have the right attitude. I have been refused entry
on the grounds that one of our entourage was laughing too loudly and was accused
of being "too boisterous". Townhouse, selective yes, racist no. Adrian,
London I was very interested to see the article on Inside Out about
nightclubs in Leeds barring clubbers on the basis of their colour...
I
wonder if anyone will be surprised to learn that clubs in Leeds are not only barring
people on the basis of their colour but ethnicity in general.
I made the
complaint because friends, family and I are so sick of being treated in the same
way because we are English Gypsies and Irish Travellers. We have lived
in this town for hundreds of years and yet still we suffer like our fellow ethnic
minority residents. The final straw, after years of tolerating this treatment
from doormen in Leeds, came on New Year's Eve.
A small group of pals,
myself included, trying to enjoy ourselves alongside everyone else were rejected
by a doorman who bluntly told us 'not tonight girls, we're not having your kind
in here tonight'. Kathleen Morrison
I am British Indian, I
can remember 10 years ago in my home town of Birmingham and not getting into Clubs,
even though me and my friends adhered to the clubs dress policy. It was
pretty obvious that as Indians we could not get into certain clubs, and seeing
our white counter parts get in use to get a bit annoying.
One of my
best friends is white and going clubbing with him was never an issue, only when
I was with my all Asian friends did I find certain clubs wouldnt let me
in. Just surprising to know it is still going on. Tulvinder Shokar
I have tried going to Townhouse twice, been refused both times. I
asked for a reason why and was told it was not in their policy to give a reason. I
asked if I was not conforming to their dress code (whilst wearing blue jeans shoes
and long sleeve shirt) so I would know for next time as I was only visiting friends
in Leeds but was just told to move on. The friends who I go out
with in Leeds are all white and have only ever been turned away once and given
the reason as - full to capacity. I am glad this has now been revealed
as it seems these that these two clubs while being prestigious are just down right
stupid to think that Black and Asian people are going to be any different than
our white counterparts we are all there to go out and have a drink and enjoy ourselves.
Wayne Me and my cousin were recently turned away from a popular
nightclub in Coventry. When asking the bouncer the reason, he explained that we
were not allowed in due to it been a "black and Asian night". As
I was meeting friends in there and they suggested I give it a try I was pretty
annoyed (they had to come out and meet me) Guess that this is OK in this
day and age, but if it was the other way round it would be a different story altogether.
Just leaves me to add... is racism a one way thing??? Leon, Coventry I'm
a recent graduate and have been going out in Leeds city centre for 5 years. Me
and my friends have also been refused entry to Townhouse a number of times, with
nothing more than "not tonight lads" as the reason. [At another
club]... me and my friend are both Sikhs and we are required to cover our hair
by our religion. Therefore when I go out clubbing I tie a patka (bandana), which
is a simple version of a turban. I have been refused entry by doorman..., saying
we do not allow bandanas in the club. This is new policy, they tell me.
I try by best to explain to them that I'm not wearing it as a fashion statement
but they say it's up to the management. I have then asked for the manager
to come out and speak to me... she too said that we will not be allowed in wearing
them. This is absurd as they have a casual dress policy (t-shirts, jeans,
trainers, some even with baseball caps) on Friday nights and we had shirts and
shoes on as well. Their policy is something new as I had no problems last
year. Now when I went last Friday they didn't say anything to me at the door and
the same people were on the door that refused me the week before. Then towards
the end of the night a doorman came up to me in the club and told me to remove
my patka. I again had to explain to him that it's for religious reasons and I
refused to take it off. He walked away and I heard nothing more about it. I
am heading back to the same club tonight for a University reunion party and I'm
am sure what will happen. As you can imagine it is impossible to plan a night
out at that club - I believe they are discriminating on the grounds of my racial
beliefs which is unfair and against the law. Also I have no problems at work wearing
a pakta and they have a smart office dress code! Gurj Singh
I have been a Doorman for 16 years, both here the UK and
in Australia/NZ, and as a white doorman working in Black clubs I have been ordered
not to let in White/Asian men on many occasions. Your story is very naive
- each club tries attract a certain crowd and whether you want admit it or not
some crowds/music don't mix and it's the Doormen who have confront the violence
and angry people so it's better to not let it happen in the first place.
Sadly
in this country there is huge amount of recreational drug use in clubs, and when
it's mixed with alcohol and bad attitudes, the outcome is a fight. Andrew
I am so pleased that this issue has been highlighted. I can
speak for a large number of young Black and Asian males who have been turned away
from The Townhouse in particular, for absolutely no reason whatsoever. Myself
and my friends are in our mid 30's and as a group of 4, 3, and even 2 have been
turned away from the Townhouse for absolutely no reason. Then we have watched,
as scores of Black and Asian men are turned away without reason, and our white
counterparts walk straight in. It has been going on so long that we have
even begun to take bets on whether we would get in or not. It's disgraceful. Speaking
for me and my friends, we are well dressed young professionals, who have never
been caught up in trouble on a night out in our lives. We have been continually
turned away from the Townhouse, like we are a bunch of drunkard teenagers. Ian
Kennedy I am writing to you regarding your programme on being
rejected from clubs on the basis of the colour of your skin. I am currently a
student at Leeds metropolitan university and part time door supervisor
I have even experienced it myself being rejected from the Townhouse many times
purely because of the colour of my skin with friends. Now I have door supervision
badge there is no excuse to class me out especially when I work there from time
to time. I know if I didn't have my badge, I would get rejected the same way as
the people in the report. There is defiantly a white policy because when
I use to try to get in before you would see people of ethic origin being rejected,
even Sikhs. I do not condone racism at all and think they should be no tolerances
for it in the multi cultural United Kingdom. I am glad that this as come out into
the open because this expresses the true representation of major clubs in Leeds
and Yorkshire. Anonymous I am 33 years old and have experienced
this problem on a regular basis over many years. I am a qualified accountant,
I work hard during the week and expect to be able to go out at the weekend and
enjoy a few drinks and the music. However on countless occasions I have been refused
entry to Townhouse. When asking why, I have been told that they don't have
to give me a reason. I have then seen large groups of white males walk in without
any problems. The earliest I have been refused was 9.50pm when they had
no queue and the place was empty. I got there early hoping to avoid all that rubbish
but me and my mixed raced friend who had travelled up from Chesterfield for a
night out were told, "not to night!" I have tried all those "splitting
it up", "go in with a white friend", "try again in an hour"
options but nine times out of ten it does not work... I have been Dj ing(
RnB,hip hop etc) for over 15 years, before RnB and Hip Hop became "commercial"...
It annoys me that places like Townhouse will play the tunes and profit from it
but won't let the people who have supported this music from day one i.e. black
and Asian people into their venue. The frustrating thing about this whole
thing is that there is no viable alternative at the moment so come on promoters
of Leeds... take on the Townhouse... there is definitely a market for it!! To
all the fellow Townhouse rejects don't suffer in silence any more... omplain to
the licensing section of the council... This place has got away with it for far
too long... Big up all the Townhouse rejects... D
After
queuing outside Townhouse for 45 minutes, me, my girlfriend and her friend were
turned away at the door. We were told by the doorman that there were too many
girls (3) in our group. In front of us was a group of seven girls who were all
white and very loud. The group of seven were allowed in without any questions
or hesitations.
The only difference between our groups were, we were black
and quiet and they were white and loud. Ricky I am also very happy
that this issue has been highlighted. I have lived in Leeds for 4 years now (I
am in my mid 20s) and ever since, neither me or my black friends have ever been
allowed into Townhouse on a regular club night. I have been lucky to get an invitation
to a party at Townhouse on a Tuesday when the doormen could not make up any excuse
to turn me away, otherwise I would not know how the insides of the place look. The
latest time I got turned away I was with two Asian girls and a black mate of mine,
and that night the doorman went to the extent of taking our money back from the
cashier to return it as he uttered the well anticipated "not tonight mate"
If you are going to turn us away when we obviously are well dressed and behaved
for your night at least be decent enough to tell us that we are too black to give
you our business! Concerned Leeds clubber My male family members
(who are, like me, black) have regularly been turned away from Town House and
Rehab. It did occur to me that this was happening too often as it was just a small
number of lads (2) queuing up to go in. I am so so so glad that this has been
brought to light. You have no idea how demoralising this is to young black people
who are law abiding and just want to go out with their friends. Thank you so much
for highlighting this matter. Jasmin Not tonight lads! Not tonight
lads! not tonight lads! These words will forever taunt me. Don't be deluded
by official government statistics. Although we're living in a multicultural multi-faith
society, racism still exists in its current form. since the introduction of the
relevant legislation, it has become more covert rather than its obvious open form
in the past. I am an Asian male from Yorkshire and used to travel to Leeds frequently
on a weekend. Both Rehab and Townhouse have in place a strict door policy
On numerous occasions I along with some friends have been turned away without
being given a valid reason. 'Not tonight lads!' Four out of five times I had been
refused entry with no explanation. The one time I did gain entry was due
to the fact I was accompanied by a group of female colleagues. The experiences
were unpleasant and very disheartening
I am disgusted and appalled by the
management at these venues and praise the investigative report uncovered by the
BBC. It has been going on for far too long. Unless to the contrary, I see
no other explanation to this matter. Leeds City Council and the SIA should
review their training and licensing objectives. Jav M. Ossett I'm
very happy this issue has been highlighted and hope something will be done about
it; I'm speaking for a large number of black people being turned away from nightclubs
in Leeds/West Yorkshire. I moved down from Birmingham myself - I used to enjoy
socialising with friends, going clubbing back in B'gham but as soon as I got here
in Leeds, I was just so put off and stressed out with the way black people are
being treated because they never let us in and never gave us reasons why we were
being turned away, and this has happened many, many times.. and the most ANNOYING
thing is that they play hip hop, rnb etc... music of black origins and they don't
want no black people in those clubs!!!! Why?? Why?? Racism??? And besides
the dooormen only allow white people inside without even looking at the way they
are dressed or anything, just because they are whites. I can assure you guys that
there are millions of frustrated and angry black people out there in Leeds and
they can't just do anything about it and thousands of white clubbers who deep
down in their heart know what is going on. So what we do is just chilling at home
or try find a club in Chapeltown etc... because going out in Leeds city centre
is not different from gambling!! And this is a real example that I have
experienced myself
we were in the queue, there was these two whites males
in front of us wearing dirty Reebok trainers with hats on, and me and my mate
both black were very well dressed (decently) shirts, jeans, leather shoes and
guess what happened?? The two white boys were let in and us turned down!!! and
the strangest thing is that it seems like black people and Asian people from Leeds
are quite use to it and find it normal now!!!! They are alright with the discrimination
going on!!!! Eric I'm Ulises, a male from Latin American (Hispanic)
origin and settled in the UK. I have also experienced direct discrimination
as I have been turned down, with no explanation whatsoever, even when I have been
dressing smart. It all comes down to my skin colour (medium dark as you can imagine).
I'm available if you would want to conduct an experiment and show that 2 out of
3 times
I will be turned down for no apparent reason. Thank you. Ulises,
Leeds I just watched the programme about the above and I was turned
away whilst out with a group of friends. I am mixed race and was out in a group
of seven. Two of us were mixed race and
we were turned away with no explanation.
We were simply told "you aren't coming in tonight". However, they
let the large number of white people behind us in and as we made our way to another
club, we saw them turning 2 black guys away but letting the white people behind
them in. We were all smartly dressed and having a laugh as it was someone's birthday
and this certainly put a dampner on things. Thank you for highlighting what
is an ever growing problem. Stacey, Leeds My name is Steve and
I'm 27 years of age & I visit the club Rehab on a regular basis. I usually
visit Rehab on a Saturday night. I really find this behaviour from the door
staff bizarre
The majority of people who visit Rehab on a Saturday
night are a mixture of black, white, Asians, gays, lesbians & transexuals
or drag queens. Although I'm not saying this incident hasn't happened, I
find this strange as speed queen's policy is to welcome all races and sexual preferences. I
find that just recently something so innocent is always been conceived as racial
prejudice. Concerned, Steve, Leeds Clubs regularly refuse entry
to black/Asian people and by law have to give no reason. These clubs in Leeds
may well have midweek 'ethnic nights' but I was under the impression that apartheid
was dead. Several years ago my mate with dreadlocks was refused admission to many
nightclubs in Sheffield on the grounds that he had dreadlocks. Their defence when
challenged by the 'race equality unit' was that they didn't let white people in
with dreadlocks... Clubs, with their 'management have the right to refuse admission'
appear to be above the law.
However, the statement by Rehab in your programme
that said that admission to the club is dependant on 'age, dress and behaviour'
is in fact illegal. They have stated quite clearly that they are prepared to refuse
admission to their Club on the grounds of age. The people refused admission to
the club in your story were clearly dressed appropriately, their behaviour was
fine and they were definitely over 18.
This Club (if they have not broken
anti race discrimination laws) should certainly be investigated under age discrimination
legislation and I reckon anyone who has any intention of going to these clubs
should think about boycotting them now. Garry It is an utter shame
that in the twenty-first century the colour of your skin determines if you are
or aren't allowed to enter a building. In fact, it's a disgrace. Towards
the end of the summer in 2006, myself and 5 other young ladies headed
for
a night out. My white mates (3) went ahead and were at the door to enter, my fourth
white mate was heading though the gate. However, myself (black) and other lady
of colour were denied entry. Or rather it was phased as "not tonight ladies".
I was utterly aghast, I stood there wondering what the matter was. I did ask why
and was told "management orders". There was no difference with myself
and my party except the colour of my skin. Never had I experienced racism
that blatant and in your face. I recall my dad's generation recapping of their
encounters because of a fact they had no control over. I had never thought that
my generation would have to experience the same insult. It often leads
you to wonder is the UK truly integrated and a metropolitan country; or are the
owners
of establishments with these policies living in the dark ages? On
the hand, I am rather please the general public has been made aware if their ignorance.
At least it is a step to eradicate underground racism. Diane H I
am so pleased that this issue has been raised. I went out at the end of November
on a Saturday night with a group of friends. There were 4 girls and 3 guys, 2
of whom were mixed race. We were queuing to get into Townhouse and when it got
to us, the mixed race guy was at the front of the queue with his white girlfriend
and they said you aren't coming in. When asked why they gave no reason and simply
said you aren't coming in tonight. As we walked away, they let all the people
behind us in and they were all white. We then walked to a club further down and
as we walked away, I looked back and saw them turning 2 black guys away but let
the white people behind them in. They therefore can't argue the club was
full, nor can they say we weren't dressed correctly as we were all smartly dressed
and had been in a number of bars earlier that evening with no problems. We weren't
even drunk and were all laughing and joking because it was someone's birthday
so there were no attitude problems. It was disgusting and I only hope everyone
boycotts the place as there is no room these days for racism. Not in such a city
that is very multi cultural and it is forever growing and striving to be bigger
and better. With this attitude, it will turn people away
Kirsty in
Leeds I myself am a 27 year old Asian male and have lived in Leeds all
my life. Since a very young age it become common knowledge that if you are planning
a night out with friends, that attempting to enter a club in groups of more than
2 would be almost impossible. The usual tactic would be usually to split into
groups where one Asian would be accompanied by a white male/female. On many occasions
this would not be possible either and we would be refused entry due to excuses
such as dress code or simply told "not tonight, too busy" where it would
be clearly evident that entry was acceptable for others. This often became
common knowledge amongst all Asian males of my age and usually resulted in many
parties being broken up and certain clubs avoided
I would like to thank
you for highlighting this issue which has been going on for as far back as I can
remember, and will hopefully now be addressed by both club owners and door staff.
However in a city which claims to offer a complete clubbing experience for all,
image seems to be precedence and if "you don't fit in, you're not going to
get in" something nearly all Asian males have had to accept over the years. Mandeep
Having watched tonight's programme I think it's a tad ironic that
you had one feature on alleged racism in a nightclub already notorious for being
difficult to get into, and another about the proliferation of political correctness.
Anyway, that aside, although the experiment seemed to expose racist door policies
I think you would need to do a much more extensive investigation to demonstrate
any consistent discrimination. Having been turned away from the Townhouse many
times since the day it opened, I would say that their main discrimination is against
men, as it is with plenty of nightclubs and bars. They are one of the toughest
though. It is very difficult to get into the Townhouse without queuing in total
silence and maintaining a completely sober attitude. Any sign of frivolity or
machismo and you won't even make it to the front of the queue, never mind inside
the bar. It's a shame the management of the club didn't have the nouse
to come out and explain their entry policy as it only serves to make them look
guilty when I believe the real issue is that they discriminate against everybody
except pretty girls. I might add, to finish, that last time I was in the Townhouse
it was absolutely packed with Black and Asian people and on a Friday night. Nick I
have had same problem... One Saturday night I was out with my mates and was not
allowed in just because I was with my Asian and Black friends, although I'm white.
I was told that the place was full and we were rejected. Just as we walked off
the white couple behind us went straight in without any questions asked. When
I saw this, I went up to the doormen and asked why there were letting them in
and not us. My boyfriend is also a doorman in one of the other clubs and
i have a very clear idea about what happens behind the scenes and I know that
it's usually group of males who aren't allowed to go in, since this may cause
problems, but I really could not understand why we were not allowed since I was
with a mixed group of friends and we weren't just black or Asian or white. Doormen
just refused to let us in, apparently it was management decision, watching us
with the camera above. But the irony is that I stood there curious to see who
was going in and every single coloured person was turned away. I think
its absolutely ridiculous to discriminate people due to their skin colour, when
in fact all they want to do is go out an have fun. I can understand that sometimes
people aren't allowed to go in because of the dress code, or they've had bit too
much to drink, but to not let people in because of their skin colour is absolute
nonsense. I would like to thank you for bringing this subject up. I'm white
and I may not understand what it feels like to be discriminated due to skin colour
but Ii certainly do not agree with racism, and I think it's time for everyone
to admit that although we live in 21st Century racism still exists. Tika
Me and friend tried getting into the Town House early last year at
a very reasonable hour (around 8ish) and it was half-full with no queue and were
refused entry, we asked why and they said that they did not need to provide a
reason. This was very infuriating because we felt we were dressed well (wearing
shoes) and only had a couple of drinks. This was the first time we had tried getting
in for about 4-5 years but even when we went round that end of Leeds the Townhouse
would regularly refuse us. We are both Caucasian. Bryan I have
experienced the same treatment from doorman in Leeds night clubs. After five working
days, I like to enjoy myself and go clubbing with friends but unfortunately, every
time I face the word - no tonight. I think some night clubs in Leeds ARE racist. DM I'm
32 white male, and have lived in Leeds all my life - except for 3 years to do
a degree in Liverpool. Every so often Friends and I will be turned away from clubs/bars
for no reason - it could be 8 o'clock just as you get out of the taxi to be told
'no'. It's bouncers on a power trip. How many of the bouncers are black and Asian?
To say they got turned away purely on race is ridiculous. What about when I get
turned away, what's the reason then? Giles We are a group of
friends who often go out in the Leeds nightlife scene.
With myself having
graduated in Leeds, I have often gone to Rehab. This was a place we before the
last year never gave any problems in letting any Asian and black males enter the
nightclub. I can now recall over the past year where me and 2 friends have been
refused several times, this being two Asian males and one black male. We have
been told the same as the lads used in the experiment, that the night was for
members only. When actually checking if there was a way to become a member
of the club, the club doesn't actually offer a membership scheme. In relation
to Townhouse - this has been renowned for never letting in certain Asian and black
people. Be this male or female. I can say that I have tried several times, dressed
to impress as I've known I would be going there but then still being turned away.
Throughout the whole of university townhouse has been known to
always turns
away Asians and blacks for no good reason. This has resulted in friends who are
girls not organising events there as they know half a crowd would not gain entry.
This also includes work parties as we would be discriminated on entry and not
visit the location. I hope that inside out can get some answers from this as it
is the truth that the show has found and I am happy that it has come to light.
Me and many friends never thought that there would be anything we could do, so
I hope that something could be changed so that we do not have to worry about entry
due to race and enjoy a fault free night out. Sunny I have been
to both venues. Rehab tends to be more of a club for dance/break beat events.
Townhouse is more an R & B club. So it is quite possible that these events
may not let in certain members of the community as when I've been previously to
Rehab, it's been mostly a white crowd and at Townhouse, a black & Asian crowd.
I've not had problems at getting into either club though
It seems
to me that clubs in Leeds really want to have separate nights for different ethnic
groups in Leeds. This seems to be more of a problem in clubs than in the bars
in Leeds, which are generally well mixed. It's almost a form of apartheid! Sarah Dance
and R&B is black music and what do most clubs play in them these days
yes Dance and R&B i.e. black music, so when you're black and being refused
entry to a club or bar and music you enjoy is being played in there, it's maddening
you shouldn't be thinking it might be because you're the wrong crowd. How can
you be
if you're dressed correctly and you're not slurring your speech and
stumbling all over the place you should be allowed in space permitting. [And
in response to another comment] I don't use or sell drugs. My friends don't use
or sell drugs, never have - it's not our scene, but I can count on both hands
the amount of times me and my friends will be asked by a white clubber on a night
if we have any drugs for sale... it's ridiculous and very sad. Steve |