Reviewer's Rating 2 out of 5   User Rating 3 out of 5
The Human Stain DVD (2004)

With his adaptation of The Human Stain, director Robert Benton managed to "drain the colour from Philip Roth's complex novel". Anthony Hopkins and Nicole Kidman are caught in a tangle of secrets and lies in a romance that mirrors the hypocrisy prevalent in all aspects of modern American life. Unfortunately, critics and audiences were almost unanimously nonplussed by this soggy rendering.

Stubborn Stains

The Human Stain DVD screengrab The behind-the-scenes featurette offered here is, frankly, painful to watch. Punctuated by staccato soundbites, it's as if cast and crew are at a loss for things to say. Of the director, Anthony Hopkins can only bring himself to effuse, "Robert Benton is surely the kindest director I've ever worked with." Kidman, meanwhile, coos, "He's such a sweetheart!"

Benton returns the compliment - while also managing to shift the blame - when he says, "The lifeblood of this movie are the actors. If this movie works, it's because of the performances." And if it doesn't work... However, he also assures us that he's "learned a lot from directing this movie", but declines to share any of these newfound insights ie there is no audio commentary.

Shoot Me

Cinematographer Jean Yves Escoffier died of heart failure shortly after The Human Stain was completed (everyone's a critic!) so a short - and we do mean short - tribute is also included on this disc. Essentially this is a montage of behind-the-scenes footage from the shoot, cobbled together with scenes from Good Will Hunting, which make for rather disorientating viewing. Furthermore, instead of a eulogy from colleagues and friends, the whole thing is overlaid with Rachel Portman's wallpaper soundtrack to The Human Stain. In short it's a lazy effort, which pretty much sums up this DVD release.

EXTRA FEATURES

  • Behind-The-Scenes featurette
  • Tribute to Jean Yves Essofier
  • Technical Information

    REGION SOUND MENUS RATIO
    2,4 Dolby Digital 5.1 Animated, with music 2.35:1 (anamorphic)
    CHAPTERS SUBTITLES AUDIO TRACKS
    21 English English
    CAPTIONS EXTRAS SUBTITLES CERTIFICATE
    English None of the special features are subtitled 18

    End Credits

    Director: Robert Benton

    Writer: Nicholas Meyer

    Stars: Anthony Hopkins, Nicole Kidman, Ed Harris, Gary Sinise, Wentworth Miller, Jacinda Barrett

    Genre: Drama, Romance

    Length: 105 minutes

    Cinema: 23 January 2004

    DVD: 23 August 2004

    Country: USA