BBC HomeExplore the BBC
This page has been archived and is no longer updated. Find out more about page archiving.

24 September 2014

BBC Homepage

Local BBC Sites

Neighbouring Sites

Related BBC Sites


Contact Us

People Like You

You are in: Cambridgeshire > Features > People Like You > In the minutes following the death of Benazir Bhutto

Benazir Bhutto

Benazir Bhutto

In the minutes following the death of Benazir Bhutto

"Thank god you are here, Benazir is dead." These words greeted Andrew Webster, a Cambridgeshire man living in Karachi, as he arrived home, just minutes after the death of Benazir Bhutto. He tells us what it's like in Pakistan right now...

I knew something was wrong as soon as I came out of the park I had just been running in. It is about a 5 minute walk to my house from where I was and through a hustling bustling street of shops which usually is crazy busy at 6:50pm. However today everything was closed, not just closed but dark and ghostly. People on the streets were hurrying around and it was an uneasy, eerie place to be.  I had only been in the park for 30 minutes.

Benazir Bhutto

My first thought was that something had happened in my neighbourhood, maybe the pizza hut next door had been robbed or something like that. But the truth of the situation became clear when I entered my front door….”Thank god you are here, Benazir is dead”. It was then an anxious wait for my last flat mate to return, who was partially caught up in the initial trouble. He eventually got home slightly shaken after having to leave his transport and walk the last 30 minutes.

My initial reaction was that it was a joke, closely followed by disbelief. It is one of those unbelievable situations. This person who has been such a central part of life in Pakistan since I arrived was shot and killed in a matter of minutes. It is a clear reminder of the fragility of life. Nowhere is it more of a reminder than in Karachi though.

Support for politicians is regionally concentrated in Pakistan and Benazir originates from the province of Sindh and lives in Karachi no more than 5 minutes from where I live.  Her popularity here was clearly shown in the welcome reception she received in October only for it to end in another instance of carnage after an attack on her life left 140 people dead.

So how does a country like Pakistan react to a tragedy like this? Well in the immediate aftermath rioting and protesting on the streets is to be expected as people express their grief and anger with what has happened. This is why the streets were empty, eerie and dark within minutes of the news. By now people know what to expect next. And for someone in the UK, this immediate reaction is difficult to relate to.

"This person who has been such a central part of life in Pakistan since I arrived was shot and killed in a matter of minutes."

Andrew Webster in Karachi

However what has become apparent to me over the last 4 months is that people here, who are engaged with the political situation, tie much greater importance and emotion to their political leaders than in the UK. Figures such as Musharraf, Sharif and Bhutto are either hated or loved by political activists in Pakistan and there is not much room for a middle ground.

What is more these figures have dominated the political arena for the last 2 decades and the Bhutto family for the entirety of Pakistan’s lifetime. People are far more connected to the people than they are the policy, and for years a great many have put their trust in Benazir to bring stability and prosperity to Pakistan.

As a result for those who have grown up with Benazir and the other Bhuttos, she was a beacon of hope.  Many who feel frustrated, angry and bitter with the way things are in Pakistan lay the solutions to their struggles at her feet.  It is not the party, but the person that carries all of the answers, so for now I imagine her supporters feel that their hope for something better has been destroyed.

This is where their anger and grief, which to many in the UK might seem extreme, comes from. Not only this but it is fuelled by the personal relationship they have built with someone who seemed to understand their struggle so aptly. And sadly for the politics of Pakistan it is all too easy to start pointing the finger at someone, usually the someone who is in power. 

Three days of mourning

So what next for me? Well a three day mourning period has been declared by General Musharraf, which means the country will come to a standstill for its duration. With the streets still very much unsafe, I imagine we will be confined to our home for a while, at least until things calm down. That means movies, BBC news and books.

Andrew Webster

Andrew Webster

I would be lying if I said I didn’t feel a little nervous about the situation and the future. But then again the danger isn’t aimed at people like me. The only real danger to me is getting caught up in something accidently and with us locked up safely in our house it would be very difficult to get into too much trouble. 

Election on hold?

As for the next few weeks, well who knows? I can’t imagine that the election will go ahead, especially as 2 of the leading political parties have already announced a boycott on it following Benazir’s death. This could bring weeks of instability. But like the country I will just take one day at a time. I’ve become attached to Pakistan though, and the thought of leaving is a painful one and something I desperately don’t want to do.

But at least I know I have the option and can escape if the going gets too tough.  But in saying this a thought has to be given to the people of Pakistan who love their country, wouldn’t leave even if they could and want to see great things for its future.

Regardless of your position on Bhutto, it is a sad sad day for Pakistan and a huge step backwards in the country’s struggle for democracy. Let’s hope the people act with restraint in their reactions and that it is not too long before it gets back on the right track.

Andrew Webster, Karachi, Thursday 27th Decemeber, 2007

last updated: 31/12/2007 at 13:26
created: 28/12/2007

Have Your Say

The BBC reserves the right to edit comments submitted.

Mubashar Hussain From Gujar khan
BB's tragic death proved she hadn't any need to collect somthing from pakistan. There was no any lust of money. She was a really devoted and brave women, even she knew that her life is at risk but she didnt stop her compaign of democracy. I was shoked when i heared about her death, it was all incredible, was not easy to be convinced about her death. I'll never forget the tragic death of BB, May God bless her peace in heaven.

MALTI SINGH, Fiji Islands
I have never met Ms Bhuuto but always admired her for her courage and love for her country. For me I came to know Pakistan because and through benazir Bhutto. This great lady will always be loved and remembered for her courage.

Briana Day
why did they kill her

Hussain Al mousawi
I wish to thank Mr Andrew Webster of this wonderfull contribution on Benazir Bhutto's assasination.But I wonder if he can find out the history of all Bhutto's family in Sind even before the formation of Pakistan. Or in short who is the original founder of Bhtto's family. What is the social position of this family in Sind. For me it looks that this family decsendent of anciant noble blood. (I feel so discussted that this noble family is treated this way to be finshed in ashort time of history in this trajick way one after another in "different reasons but one dower")I know it is not an easy task but it will be so apriciated if this can be done. It is just to record to history that people are awake not just in Pakistan but in all round the world.Many thanksand kindest regards

Muhammad Abbas
We miss her. I will never forget Benazir Bhutto Jeyay Bhutto

Monica Gul
She was a great leader and her untimely sudden death is a great loss.We'll miss her all of our life and we'll always love you BB.

Rasheed Ali
Mr Anrew, you are quite right, she was a ray of hope for the dowtrodden people of Pakistan. I have never been a PPP voter, but one thing I know very well that there is no politician in Pakistan who could be compared with BB. She was brilliant, intelligent and insightful. May God have mercy on Pakistan and Pakistanis. [Edited comment]

Abdul Aziz
BB I have not any words to praise you. I am so sad. I will miss you so much. May Allah bless you. All i promise you is that I will continue your mission until my last breath.

Ansab Rehman
She is very good and brave women.We miss her our hole life.I hope ALLAh blessing on him.

Syeda Saima Bukhari
i'm so sad over her death and i wish whoever done this, punished him. i pray for her always and i'll not forget Ms BB.

Paul Sloss
Thinking of you mate!Speak to you soon!

You are in: Cambridgeshire > Features > People Like You > In the minutes following the death of Benazir Bhutto



About the BBC | Help | Terms of Use | Privacy & Cookies Policy